Labor Induction for First-Time Moms: What the SAINT Drug Trial Found
A large Norwegian randomised trial in The BMJ tested two drugs, hyoscine butylbromide and sodium bicarbonate, in induced labor for first-time mothers. Neither clearly raised the chance of a spontaneous vaginal birth. Here is what that means, and what official guidance says about induction.
Published November 19, 2026 · By Egspect Editorial
A new randomised trial in The BMJ tested whether two drugs could help first-time mothers have a vaginal birth after labor induction, and the answer was no clear benefit. In the SAINT trial, 2,963 first-time mothers in Norway were given sodium bicarbonate, hyoscine butylbromide, both, or placebo during induced labor. About 56% to 61% had a spontaneous vaginal birth in every group, and none of the differences were statistically significant.
If you are facing an induction, this is no cause for worry. The trial tested add-on drugs that are not part of standard care, so nothing in your induction plan changes. This guide explains what the trial did, what it can and cannot show, and what official guidance says about how induction works. It is general information, not medical advice. For your own pregnancy, talk to your midwife or obstetrician.
TL;DR
| Question | Short answer |
|---|---|
| What was tested? | Sodium bicarbonate and hyoscine butylbromide, alone and together, during induced labor |
| Who took part? | 2,963 first-time mothers with a single term baby, at 11 Norwegian hospitals |
| What was the main result? | No drug clearly increased spontaneous vaginal birth |
| Does my induction change? | No. These drugs are not standard parts of induction |
| Is induction a choice? | Yes. The NHS says "It's your choice whether to have your labour induced or not" |
| Is it more painful? | Usually, says the NHS, but pain relief options are not restricted |
| How long does it take? | Usually many hours, per the NHS |
What did the SAINT trial test?
SAINT stands for Safe Induction of Labor Trial. It is registered on ClinicalTrials.gov as NCT05719467, and its protocol was published in BMJ Open in 2025. The results were published in The BMJ in 2026. We could not open the full paper, so the figures below come from the publisher's own summary (BMJ Group press release) and matching news coverage (Medical Xpress), not from the paper itself. Check the paper for exact numbers and confidence intervals.
Per those summaries, the trial was multicentre, randomised, placebo-controlled and "factorial", meaning the two drugs were tested separately and together. It enrolled 2,963 first-time mothers with a single term baby who were having labor induced, at 11 Norwegian hospitals between January 2023 and January 2025.
At the onset of active labor, participants were randomly assigned to one of four groups:
- oral sodium bicarbonate plus intravenous hyoscine butylbromide
- sodium bicarbonate plus an intravenous placebo
- hyoscine butylbromide plus an oral placebo
- a double placebo
Doses were repeated every four hours, up to three doses. Participants, staff, investigators and the people assessing outcomes did not know who got what. That masking is a strength, because it limits bias.
Why would anyone try these drugs?
The published protocol (BMJ Open, 2025) describes the rationale. Hyoscine butylbromide is an antispasmodic that might relax the cervix and help it dilate. Sodium bicarbonate was proposed to counteract a build-up of lactate in the uterine muscle. The protocol says earlier trials were mixed or unblinded and not focused on induction, and that no rigorous randomised trials had yet tested either drug's effect on how babies are born. So the question was reasonable, and a clear answer is useful to the people who write guidelines.
What were the results?
The main outcome was spontaneous vaginal birth, meaning a vaginal birth without forceps, ventouse (vacuum) or caesarean. According to the BMJ Group summary:
| Group | Spontaneous vaginal birth |
|---|---|
| Bicarbonate plus hyoscine | 57% (422 of 741) |
| Bicarbonate alone | 61% (445 of 734) |
| Hyoscine alone | 61% (449 of 741) |
| Double placebo | 56% (422 of 747) |
No differences reached statistical significance, and serious adverse events were similar across groups. The authors concluded that neither agent "clearly increased spontaneous vaginal birth", and that routine use is not supported.
What does "no clear benefit" mean?
It means the trial did not show that the drugs help. It does not mean they were proven to do nothing. The authors say small benefits cannot be excluded, because trials have limited precision. The two single-drug groups were about 5 percentage points above placebo, but that gap could have arisen by chance, and the combined group did not follow the same pattern. A fair reading is: no reliable effect was seen, so these drugs should not become routine on this evidence.
What are the limits?
Based on the report, three points are worth knowing:
- Timing. The drugs were given at the onset of active labor, regardless of how labor was progressing. A different timing or a group with slow labor could behave differently.
- Population. Everyone was a first-time mother with a single term baby in Norway. Women who were not proficient in Norwegian or English were excluded, which may limit how far the findings apply elsewhere.
- One trial. A single study, however large, adds to the evidence rather than closing the topic.
None of these limits gives a reason to expect a benefit. They simply show where the study's findings stop.
Does this change how my labor will be induced?
No. Neither drug is described as a standard part of induction in the ACOG and NHS pages we read, and this trial does not alter the routine methods they describe. Here is what those bodies say.
Why is labor induced?
The NHS says induction is offered if labour has not started naturally by 41 weeks, because the risk of stillbirth or other problems rises. It may also be offered if your waters break more than 24 hours before labour starts, or for health reasons such as diabetes, high blood pressure, intrahepatic cholestasis of pregnancy or a baby not growing well.
ACOG lists similar reasons, including pregnancy past 41 to 42 weeks, problems with the placenta, low amniotic fluid, and preeclampsia. It also describes elective induction, when you and your baby are healthy and you choose it, and says "Elective induction should not be done before 39 weeks of pregnancy." It notes that induction may be considered for healthy women at 39 weeks to reduce the chance of cesarean birth.
How is labor induced?
Both bodies describe a similar set of options, and your team picks based on how ready your cervix is:
- Membrane sweep. The NHS says it is usually offered after 39 weeks. A clinician sweeps a finger around the cervix, which may release prostaglandins and start labour. It can cause cramping or bleeding afterwards.
- Prostaglandins. Hormones given as a vaginal pessary or gel, or by mouth, to soften the cervix. ACOG notes some are not used after a previous cesarean or uterine surgery.
- Devices. A balloon catheter or rods or sponges that swell to widen the cervix.
- Oxytocin. A hormone given by IV drip. ACOG says contractions usually start about 30 minutes after it is given, with monitoring of you, your contractions and your baby's heart rate.
- Breaking the waters (amniotomy). A clinician makes a hole in the amniotic sac, which can start or strengthen contractions.
The NHS adds that induction always takes place in a hospital maternity unit and that these treatments usually take "many hours" to work.
Is an induced labor more painful?
The NHS says induced labour is usually more painful than labour that starts on its own, and that induction does not restrict your pain relief, which includes an epidural and water birth. If this worries you, raise it with your midwife before the day so you know your options.
What are the risks?
ACOG lists these risks of induction:
- Overstimulation of the uterus with oxytocin, which can change the baby's heart rate. If there are heart rate concerns, oxytocin may be reduced or stopped.
- Chorioamnionitis, an infection of the amniotic fluid, placenta or membranes.
- Infection of the baby.
- Rupture of the uterus, which ACOG calls rare.
The NHS adds that induced labour is more likely to need assisted delivery with forceps or ventouse, and that induction may not work. You may then be offered another method, a caesarean, or a reassessment after a few hours. ACOG says that if you and your pregnancy are doing well, you may be given the option to go home and try again.
Is it my choice to be induced?
Yes. The NHS puts it plainly: "It's your choice whether to have your labour induced or not." That includes asking why it is being recommended, how likely it is to work, what the alternatives are, and what extra monitoring would mean if you wait. A good question for your midwife is: "What is the risk to me and my baby of waiting, and of induction, in my situation?"
Feeling uneasy is normal. Hospital induction can mean a long wait and an unfamiliar room. Ask whether you can walk about, and when your partner or support person can stay.
When to call your midwife or doctor
Call your maternity unit or triage line straight away, whatever the stage of pregnancy, if you have:
- reduced baby movements
- vaginal bleeding
- your waters breaking, or a trickle of fluid
- regular, strengthening contractions before your planned induction date
- a severe headache with vision changes, or sudden swelling of the face and hands
- constant, severe abdominal pain
- fever or feeling unwell
These match the warning signs in our pregnancy warning signs guide. After an induction, tell your team if you have heavy bleeding, fever, worsening pain or foul-smelling discharge. If you are ever unsure, call. Maternity teams would rather hear from you than not.
What you can do now
- Ask your team why induction is being suggested and what the alternative is.
- Ask which method they plan and how long they expect it to take. There is usually no fixed answer, but they can describe the steps.
- Plan your pain relief. Ask about your options, including an epidural, and decide what you would like to try first.
- Pack for a longer stay. Our hospital bag checklist and free hospital bag checklist tool can help.
- Check your dates. Induction timing depends on your due date, so see how it is worked out in how doctors calculate your due date, or use the free due date calculator.
- Know your labour signs. If labour might start on its own first, the free labor signs checker and contraction timer can help you describe what is happening when you call.
- Share the plan with your partner. The guide for fathers and partners explains how a partner can help.
- Do not ask for add-on drugs because of headlines. This trial found no clear benefit, and routine use is not supported.
Sources and related reading
Official and primary sources
- The BMJ (2026), SAINT trial, DOI 10.1136/bmj-2026-101069
- ClinicalTrials.gov: SAINT, Safe Induction of Labor Trial (NCT05719467)
- NHS: Inducing labour
- ACOG: Labor induction FAQ
- BMJ Group press release on the trial
- BMJ Open (2025): SAINT protocol
- Medical Xpress news report on the trial (news peg only)
Related Egspect guides and tools
- Pregnancy warning signs
- How doctors calculate your due date
- Hospital bag checklist: what you actually need
- Pregnancy guide for fathers and partners
- Due date calculator
- Labor signs checker
- Contraction timer
This guide is general information, not medical advice. Facts were accurate as of November 19, 2026; guidance changes, so check with your care team.
Frequently asked questions
What did the SAINT trial find about drugs in labor induction?
In a randomised trial of 2,963 first-time mothers in Norway, published in The BMJ, neither sodium bicarbonate nor hyoscine butylbromide, alone or combined, clearly increased spontaneous vaginal birth compared with placebo. The authors say routine use is not supported.
Is labor induction safe?
Induction is a common, established procedure offered when the benefits of birth outweigh waiting. ACOG lists risks including overstimulated contractions that change the baby's heart rate, infection, and rarely uterine rupture. Your team monitors you and your baby closely. Ask them what applies to you.
How long does labor induction take?
The NHS says induction treatments usually take many hours to work, and you will usually stay in hospital. There is no fixed time, because it depends on how ready your cervix is. Ask your maternity team what to expect in your case.
Is induced labor more painful?
The NHS says induced labour is usually more painful than labour that starts on its own, and that induction does not restrict your pain relief options, which include an epidural. Talk through your preferences with your midwife beforehand.
When is labor induction recommended?
The NHS offers induction if labour has not started by 41 weeks, or earlier for reasons such as waters breaking early, diabetes, high blood pressure or poor baby growth. ACOG also lists pregnancy past 41 to 42 weeks and elective induction from 39 weeks. It is your choice.
Can I refuse labor induction?
Yes. The NHS says it is your choice whether to have your labour induced. Ask your team about the benefits, risks and alternatives, including waiting with extra monitoring, so you can decide with the full picture.
Egspect keeps pregnancy weeks, baby milestones and shared family logs ready without making the day feel like a medical dashboard.
Create my family space